Cookies should always be wonderful, and it always baffles me that they so frequently are not. Their chemistry and our biology should ensure that they are always amazing. What are three of the most important things that we need to make stuff taste good? Sugar, fat and salt. That's essentially cookies right there, with a few things cut in to give them substance and flavor. You don't even need to cook the damn things and they're delicious.
How can you mess that up? Part of the problem is that I think people try to make things too complicated or too cute or healthy. To prevent this, here are my guildelines to guaranteed good cookies, followed by a set of links to failsafe recipes that I use. I've listed my own modifications if you want to be extra naughty:
The Guidelines:
1. NO healthy substitutions are permitted. Be honest with yourself. If you were really concerned about your health or getting rid of that stubborn belly fat, you wouldn't be eating cookies in the first place, so why not actually enjoy them? Applesauce is no more a substitute for butter than gravel is a substitute for chocolate chips. Many of these items are chemically necessary for your cookies to behave properly - this is why you don't cut out milk or eggs from a recipe that calls for both. Frankly you should know better. Avocados for butter? Get out of my kitchen!
2. Remember the key acronym: ATM. No, not that version. Nor the other one. Always Trust the Mormons. The Mormon church, in its cruel wisdom is always attempting to harness the white hot sexual energy surging through its adolescent children and divert it towards aprurient activities. For boys, this means sports and random violence. For girls, they prefer activities that will ostensibly help prepare them for marriage. Like baking. Or knitting. Or scrapbooking. Anyways, if you've ever eaten cookies made by a Mormon friend you'd know what I'm talking about. They're glorious.
3. Don't leave the kitchen. Timing and temperature are two additional keys to making your food taste good, so it does you no good if you're dicking around on your computer, not realizing that your oven is actually 20 degrees too hot and your soft oatmeal cookies are now chipboard. Our oven is so terrible that it's actually impossible to predict how hot the interior will be at any given moment, so this is doubly important for me.
4. Use baking paper. It's way easier and more effective than silicon sheets, which don't crisp the bottom properly.
5. Halve the recipes. Most of them are made for large families of doughy, inert children and you'll wind up with more cookies than you can conscionably dispose of.
Here are a few excellent recipes for your run of the mill cookies. I've tried all of these, so if they turn out poorly, it's probably your fault:
Oatmeal Raising Cookies - I added about a teaspoon and a half of cinnamon, a dash of clove, a bit more salt and twice the vanilla.
Lemon Cookies - A contest winner from among Mormon bakers. No bullshit, these are good. No mods needed.
Chocolate Chip Cookies - A good basic recipe that doesn't skimp on the vanilla.
Also Chocolate Chip Cookies - A more advanced recipe that is amazing.
Snickerdoodles - This is a heavyweight among sugar cookies. Always use the butter only recipes, half-crisco has half the flavor. Add some almond extract if you want to blow some minds.
That should do you. Peanut Butter cookies have been left off because I don't make them a lot since peanut butter is pricey and bad here. I also do a great chocolate cookie, but you may as well make brownies.
Cheers.
How can you mess that up? Part of the problem is that I think people try to make things too complicated or too cute or healthy. To prevent this, here are my guildelines to guaranteed good cookies, followed by a set of links to failsafe recipes that I use. I've listed my own modifications if you want to be extra naughty:
The Guidelines:
1. NO healthy substitutions are permitted. Be honest with yourself. If you were really concerned about your health or getting rid of that stubborn belly fat, you wouldn't be eating cookies in the first place, so why not actually enjoy them? Applesauce is no more a substitute for butter than gravel is a substitute for chocolate chips. Many of these items are chemically necessary for your cookies to behave properly - this is why you don't cut out milk or eggs from a recipe that calls for both. Frankly you should know better. Avocados for butter? Get out of my kitchen!
2. Remember the key acronym: ATM. No, not that version. Nor the other one. Always Trust the Mormons. The Mormon church, in its cruel wisdom is always attempting to harness the white hot sexual energy surging through its adolescent children and divert it towards aprurient activities. For boys, this means sports and random violence. For girls, they prefer activities that will ostensibly help prepare them for marriage. Like baking. Or knitting. Or scrapbooking. Anyways, if you've ever eaten cookies made by a Mormon friend you'd know what I'm talking about. They're glorious.
3. Don't leave the kitchen. Timing and temperature are two additional keys to making your food taste good, so it does you no good if you're dicking around on your computer, not realizing that your oven is actually 20 degrees too hot and your soft oatmeal cookies are now chipboard. Our oven is so terrible that it's actually impossible to predict how hot the interior will be at any given moment, so this is doubly important for me.
4. Use baking paper. It's way easier and more effective than silicon sheets, which don't crisp the bottom properly.
5. Halve the recipes. Most of them are made for large families of doughy, inert children and you'll wind up with more cookies than you can conscionably dispose of.
Here are a few excellent recipes for your run of the mill cookies. I've tried all of these, so if they turn out poorly, it's probably your fault:
Oatmeal Raising Cookies - I added about a teaspoon and a half of cinnamon, a dash of clove, a bit more salt and twice the vanilla.
Lemon Cookies - A contest winner from among Mormon bakers. No bullshit, these are good. No mods needed.
Chocolate Chip Cookies - A good basic recipe that doesn't skimp on the vanilla.
Also Chocolate Chip Cookies - A more advanced recipe that is amazing.
Snickerdoodles - This is a heavyweight among sugar cookies. Always use the butter only recipes, half-crisco has half the flavor. Add some almond extract if you want to blow some minds.
That should do you. Peanut Butter cookies have been left off because I don't make them a lot since peanut butter is pricey and bad here. I also do a great chocolate cookie, but you may as well make brownies.
Cheers.